A Visit to "Anasazi Land"
October 1991
Dear Cha-Wel-Dor-Sue,
The
southwestern part of the USA has intrigued us ever since Pat and I
spent a week in a time share at Santa Fe, New Mexico. It was on that
trip that a real introduction to the history, culture, and arts and
crafts of the American Indian occurred, and a real urge developed to
know more about them. Visits to Pueblo, Taos and San Ildefonso gave
us some insights as to their adobe type of dwellings and agricultural
pursuits, and provided the stimulus required to return to this area.
A subsequent time share stay in Ruidoso, New Mexico, afforded us a
further opportunity to explore the Indian tribes by a stop at the
Mescaleros tribal headquarters, one of the Apache tribes.
While
in Oklahoma City with my son Wells, I visited the Oklahoma State
Museum of the American Indian and was tremendously impressed with
their many colorful diaramas. Out of this visit came the knowledge of
our forced migrations of our native American Indians from the
Carolinas, Georgia and Florida to reservations in the northeast
corner of the state. These tribes that were displaced were the
Seminoles, Choctaws, Creeks, Chichasaus and the Cherokees. It was
shocking to learn how we mistreated and manhandled our native
citizens. As a result of these visits, I responded affirmatively to
an appeal by the Smithsonian Institution for support to establish in
Washington, DC, on the Mall, a National Museum of the Indian. It is
surprising how one's sense of guilt, based on one's country's
misbehavior, prompts one to try to make amends to our American
Indians!
With
this preamble, one can understand why Pat and I decided to fly to
Albuquerque, New Mexico, rent a car, and head west toward the "Four
Corners" or that area where the states of New Mexico, Arizona, Utah,
and Colorado meet each other. It is sometimes called "Canyon Lands",
as this is where the Colorado plateau (geological) has been deeply
cut by various rivers, most of which are tributaries of the Colorado
River and the San Juan River. It is also called the land of the
"Anasazi", or the land of the cliff dwellers, who built their adobe
multi-storied houses in alcoves high on the cliffs or escarpments of
the canyons. Others built their (pit) houses on the tops of mesas
while still others lived in the fertile valleys below and were more
nomadic in type. The word "Anasazi" means unknowns or ancients and
they are considered as prehistoric people in that no written record
of their presence exists today. These early people lived from around
Christ to somewhere around 1200 or 1300 AD and then suddenly, all of
these people migrated elsewhere. Thus, all of the ruins that we saw
at Mesa Verde and Chaco Canyon were occupied probably from 1100 to
1300 AD and then within a period of 150 years, abandoned their homes.
This may have been due to unfavorable weather conditions such as
droughts and prompted them to move to the southeast along the Rio
Grande River.
Our
first stop on our trip was "Sky City" at Acoma, some 65 miles west of
Albuquerque. It is an ancient pueblo still partially occupied by
descendants of the cliff dwellers who sought refuge high on the great
"Rock of Acuso", a flat type mesa 357 feet high, about the height of
a 40 story building!
The
name Acoma means "People of the White Rock", and they probably
elected to live in this fortress-like abode to escape the warring
Apaches to the south. Today, one can be driven to the very top of
this mesa, which occupies approximately 70 acres, in a tribal bus, a
service provided for a fee by the local Acoma tribe. It is considered
to be among the oldest continuously occupied settlements in the US.
On top, there are probably 200 or so one and two and three story
buildings made of stone and adobe. Outside of many of these houses
there were some of the local inhabitants, mostly women, who were
displaying their pottery and offering it for sale. Most of the
pottery that we observed were pieces of "Traditional" pottery, the
shapes created by the hands of the potter, as contrasted to that
which was made in molds or using green ware. Each artist had created
their own designs and decorations and it was the first time I ever
stopped long enough to examine, admire, appreciate and want to
possess a piece of pottery! The highest point in Sky City is the
Church of San Estevan built by Father Ramirez between 1629 and 1641,
and rarely used today except for yearly services to commemmorate
Saint Stephen's Day, their patron saint. Most of the Acoma tribe live
today in Acomita, a town of approximately 2700 people.
One
of the reasons that I was fascinated with the pottery in this area
was when I learned how it was created and how it was finally built up
into its definitive form. Coils of clay will be rolled by hand and
then laid down one coil on top of the other. At no time was a
potter's wheel employed! After modeling, the surface was left ribbed
or made smooth by scraping with a sharp-edged tool, possibly a bit of
gourd, broken shard, or fragment of obsidian. After the decoration is
completed, firing occurs and this is done in the kiln using dried
cakes of sheep dung as fuel. The final color depends on the origin of
the clay (chemical composition) and on the duration of the exposure
of the pottery to the smoke in the kiln.
Gallup,
New Mexico, was our first overnight stop and the city consists
largely of a long commercial strip on the old US Route 66. It seemed
that every other building along this strip was selling Indian jewelry
and virtually half of the outlets restricted their sales to
wholesalers or dealers. Gallup, undoubtedly, is the Indian jewelry
capital of the United States and all tribes, regardless of their
locations, funnel their jewelry into Gallup for sale. Apparently,
jewelry-making is a cottage industry and no factories with production
lines exist. This accounts for the marked variety of designs and for
the fact that very few pieces are production items. Buses go out from
these dealer shops to the reservations to pick up the jewelry. Every
attempt on my part to visit an Indian's home was unsuccessful. They
are either shy or guard their technique or expertise carefully. We
did, however, visit the stores where all of the materials used to
make the jewelry were available for purchase by the Indians. Rough
turquoise, coral, mother of pearl, various rocks, and silver wire and
fetiches were all on display and for sale.
After
leaving Gallup, we drove southwest to Zuni and its reservation,
expecting to find a great deal of interest. No one could have been
more disappointed. It is a sleeping town with a gas station, a few
grocery stores, a couple of souvenir shops selling Zuni jewelry,
pottery, weaving, and wallhangings. We did visit the Zuni Craftsman
Cooperative Association where a few pieces of jewelry were displayed.
We were even given a catalog and could order from it if we so desired
after we returned home. We had been forewarned that there was very
little of interest to see in Zuni but we had to see it for ourselves.
My real reason for wanting to visit Zuni was that of all of the
Indian jewelry that I had previously seen in my experience, it was
the most delicate and exquisite of them all. Their needlework and
channelwork inlay designs were the ones that fascinated me most of
all.
Leaving
Zuni, we drove west on Route 40 to visit the Painted Desert and the
Petrified Forest. Each abuts the other with the Desert being in the
north and the Forest being in the south, and we used our Senior
Citizens Golden Passport card for our admission tickets. Once again,
I applauded our Department of the Interior and our National Park
Service for providing this free entry for our nation's elderly
citizens. Fortunately for us, the day was a crystal clear and
cloudless one and we could appreciate the wide range of colors
reflecting from the Chinle Geological Formation. The beauty of the
desert is definitely a function of light and shadow, and if seen on a
cloudy day could be "only a grayish washed-out line of cliffs with no
relief and no color". One reporter once claimed he saw 168 distinct
colors and shades in the sands of the Desert, and mentioned a
''rainbow of pinks and reds, and oranges, and whites and browns and
blues and grays and greens". There is virtually no vegetation except
for a few short shrubs and grasses.
The
Visitors Center at the desert was of adobe construction and we were
given a brochure and map describing the many scenic features of the
area. A ranger briefed us on the virtues of each of the lookout
points and recommended certain stops for their unique features. A 17
minute film introduced us to the Petrified Forest and how wood is
petrified. After getting back in our car, we noted there were eight
overlooks and we stopped at half of them, long enough to appreciate
the magnificent display of colors provided by the forces of erosion
(wind, water, thaw-freeze, etc.) as they carved canyons, large and
small, through this high dry table land that was once a vast flood
plain crossed by many streams.
As
we drove south into the Petrified Forest, we came upon increasing
numbers of petrified trees and noted with some disappointment that
one cannot take anything from the park, and no souvenirs of petrified
wood may be removed from the park. However, in gift shops outside of
the park, there are many pieces for sale, rough or polished, and
these were secured from petrified trees lying all about the general
area but not included within the confines of the park proper. The
colors of the natural fragments are muted, whereas the polished ones
show startling, crystal-like patterns and are very
beautiful.
The
story of the Petrified Forest began some 225 million years ago in the
late Triassic Period, when the entire area was a vast flood plain.
Tall, stately pine trees grew in the western area at the headwaters
of many streams, and crocodile-like reptiles, giant fish-eating
amphibians, and small dinosaurs lived among a variety of ferns and
other plants that are only known as fossils today. Through time,
storms, floods, earthquakes, and the like, the tall trees fell and
were washed down by swollen streams into the plains below. There,
they were covered by silt, mud, and volcanic ash and this blanket of
deposits cut off all oxygen and slowed the logs' decay. Gradually,
silicabearing ground waters seeped through the logs and bit by bit,
encased the original wood tissues with silica deposits. Slowly, the
process continued, the silica crystallized into the quartz, and the
logs were preserved as petrified wood.
Later
in geologic time, the whole area sank, was flooded and covered with
freshwater sediments. Later, the area was uplifted far above sea
level and this uplift created stresses that cracked the giant logs.
Still later in time, wind and water washed away the accumulated
layers of hardened sediments, exposing the petrified logs and the
fossilized plants and animals. Studies have revealed that fossils and
petrified woods still lie below the surface at depths of 300
feet!
We
stopped at all the viewpoints and each has something special to
observe, although we did not find the petrocliffs at Newspaper
Rock.
After
leaving the desert and forest, we drove north through a bit of
relatively flat land and were surprised at the absence of traffic on
the road. It was early July and mobile America should have been on
the move, enioying their vacations, or was Canyon deChelly of little
or no interest to them? We were aware that we were in the midst of a
recession and felt this might be partly responsible. At any event, we
drove on and spent the night in Chinle, Arizona, and it appeared
relatively deserted. We were in Navajo territory and not much was
doing.
Several
years ago, I purchased virtually a complete set of brochures or books
of our National Parks and prior to leaving on our trip, I looked over
the one called Canyon deChelly and decided that this was too
beautiful to miss. The word deChelly is taken from the Spanish and
pronounced de-shay.
Canyon
deChelly has been the "home" for American Indians for over 2000
years, and at first, it was a temporary home for bands of wandering
archaic hunters. Later, it fostered the flourishing Anasazi
civilizations among its rock walls and today, it is home to the
Navajos. Their farms and hogans are still seen in the Canyon. Our
visit included stops at both the north and south rims and we chose to
do it on our own. Guides, however, were available and we could have
elected to take a four wheel all-terrain vehicle and motor down into
the canyon itself, but we declined to do this because of Pat's back
problems. Viewing the gorge from above, one notes that is is deep and
awesome and again, impresses one with the force of a stream and the
effect of gravitation. It was on a view from the south rim that we
saw "The White House" and our first sight of a cliff dwelling. Later,
at Mesa Verde, we were to see many of them.
While
at the canyon, we did learn something of the Indians' traditional
relationship with the land, and that for all Indians, the entire
earth is a living being, and that all things, animals, plants, rocks,
rivers, and clouds, are alive and intradependent. For the Indian,
there is a balance between man and nature and they strive to maintain
it through their entire lives. For the Indian, the earth is "Mother
Earth", and the sky "Father Sky", and the Indians show their respect
in care one normally shows to one's biological mother. They are
perhaps the original environmentalists, and this feature of their
culture, I might add, is not unique to the American Indian, as I
observed it among some of the primitive tribes in both Borneo and
Sumatra.
Following
our visit to Canyon deChelly, we drove north, crossed over into Utah
(Land of the Utes) and elected not to visit Natural Bridges National
Park, as it was 60 miles out of our way and in order to actually get
to the site of the bridges, one would have to undertake a long hike
on foot for several miles. Moab, Utah, was our home for the evening
and to our surprise, there were few vacancies available at the
motels. It was the Fourth of July and to our surprise, an additional
charge of $5 was assessed to the visitors. We presume it was to pay
for the fireworks that were displayed in the evening. Since it was
early in the afternoon and the sun was still high, we drove north to
visit the spectacular Arches National Park. At this point, I might
add that my classmate at Trinity College, Jerry Wykoff, in his book
on land forms, tells us that canyons begin as rivers that carve out
their meandering path by water erosion and then later, other agents
help to widen the cut. Water seeps into cracks in the rocks and
freezes, thus exerting enormous pressure that results in exfoliation
or peeling off of huge slabs from the canyon walls. Tree roots also
dislodge slabs of rock that tumble down into the canyon. Water and
weak acids dissolve the cement of the rock and decompose it until
eventually, the rocks again become sand and are blown away by the
wind. These weathering and erosioning agents are part of the Indians
conception of a living and changing earth.
Perhaps
the most beautiful geological expression of Mother Nature that we saw
was the Arches National Park, and the beauty of this area can be
summarized by the introductory remarks in "Arches, The Story Behind
the Scenery". "Grain by grain, bit by bit, water and time have
sculpted the arid land into an infinity of forms, towering spires,
sheer cliffs, balanced rocks, and graceful arches of stone. This
giant rock garden seems rugged and changeless, but it is always
evolving and continuously being reshaped by erosion. It is a wondrous
place in which to feel the power of time."
The
park contains more than 950 natural arches, the greatest
concentration in the world. Most of the arches are of soft red
sandstone deposited over 150 million years ago in a vast desert. As
the underlying salt deposits dissolved, the sand-stone collapsed and
weathered into a mass of vertical rock called fins. Sections of these
fins wore through, thus creating the spectacular arches.
The
Scenic Drive takes one through "The Devil's Garden", "Windows",
"Courthouse and Towers", "Petrified Dunes", "Balanced Rock" and
"Garden of Eden". My words cannot adequately describe our impression
of these sites, but perhaps my video camera and Pat's Olympus slides
can provide some evidence of the beauty of this area.
As
I said, we visited this area in the late afternoon and time did not
permit us to see the "Landscape Arch", which is some 360 feet long,
nor the "Delicate Arch", as these entailed long walks and the sun had
already begun to set. At this point in our journey, the Arches was
the most inspiring and impressive of our visits to Canyon
Country.
Canyonlands
National Park was our next visit and this was done on the morning of
July 5th. As we approached the Visitors Center, there was a haze
created by billions and billions of gnats and they were with us
everywhere. I am sure our impression of this remarkable Park was
diminished by our inability to get them out of our eyes, ears, nose
and mouth!
The
Green River and the Colorado River merge in Canyonlands and due to
erosion, there is an "Island in the Sky" surrounded by vast canyons
on all sides. Our visit to Canyonlands did not include a visit to
another section called "Needles" at the southern end of the park nor
to the "Maze" at the western end of the Park. John Wesley Powell, who
explored the Colorado River in 1869, scaled the canyon walls at the
Confluence and discovered a strangely carved landscape, a "Wilderness
of Rocks".
We
drove the entire road on the "Island in the Sky" and managed to reach
each of the scenic sites, terminating in the Grand View Point
Overlook, directly below which is Monument Basin where stone columns
(Buttes) rise more than 300 feet from the canyon floor. Billions of
years of geological erosion beholds the eyes of the visitor, much as
one sees, in much greater fashion, in the views of the Grand Canyon,
the most remarkable calendar of geological time! The vegetation we
saw was largely yucca plants, pinyon trees and juniper shrubs. Cactus
and sagebrush were also prevalent.
Our
next visit was Delta, Colorado, to re-visit my Trinity classmate Lou
Giffen and his wife Kay. In so doing, we drove along the Colorado
River and had remarkable views of the canyon or gorge created by this
remarkable river. Seeing it by car relieved me of the desire that I
had had to see it in a rubber inflated craft. There were, along this
stretch of the river, very few rapids, and nothing exciting at this
particular portion of the Colorado River. While in Moab, we did miss
the opportunity to see a "Light and Sound Show", with appropriate
music on our only night's stay in Moab. Our night in Delta was spent
at the Riverwood Motel, along the Gunnison River, and it was this
river that carved a 2000 foot deep gorge that we saw on the following
day. Since one's approach to the black gorge of the Gunnison is on a
gradual incline over relatively flat territory, it comes as a great
surprise when one reaches the summit and then looks down into this
massive gorge. The narrowness of the gorge really enhances the
feeling of the tremendous depth of the gorge itself.
Lou
and I were classmates at Trinity College and he was one whom I
admired throughout our four years at college together. He was our
Valedictorian and Outstanding Scholar and, in fact, his valedictory
address was delivered in Latin! None of his classmates knew what in
the world he was talking about but we all assumed he had something
worthwhile to say. In the evening, Lou and Kay stopped by and picked
us up and took us out to dinner at a delightful spot and there, we
reminisced a great deal about our student days together. In the
morning, Lou and Kay served breakfast to us on their lovely terrace
and provided us with a beautiful view of the mountains to the east.
Lou, upon graduation from Trinity, went off to Harvard Medical School
and then later, took his surgical internship at Bellevue Hospital in
New York on the Cornell Division. Subsequently, he was a Fellow in
Surgery at the Mayo Clinic and returned to the Hartford area to do
General Surgery at the Hartford Hospital. Upon his retirement, he
built a villa in LaJijic in Mexico on Lake Chapala just south of
Guadalajara. We visited them during one of our trips in this
area.
Durango,
Colorado, had always been one of our future destinations and we
headed south after leaving Delta. Our first stop was Silverton,
formerly a rich mining town high in the San Carlos Mountains. It had
been our intention to take the Durango-Silverton Steam Train and to
view the scenery in this area but after driving our car along the
mountain passes, we decided that we were not going to carry out our
original plans and take this beautiful train ride. We did cross a
pass at 10,200 feet and also one at 11,000 feet and these were the
two highest passes that we had ever driven except for Independence
Pass just south of Aspen, Colordao.
We
spent the night in Durango and the following morning, drove on to
Mesa Verde (in Spanish, means green table). It requires a minimum of
two days to visit and since we only spent a full day there, we missed
more than half of it. We stayed at a lodge situated next to the
Visitors Center as we would have lost a great deal of time driving to
and from the Park had we chosen to stay in Cortez, Colorado. It is at
Mesa Verde that there is the largest concentration of cliff dwellings
anywhere in the world and here, archaeologists have located more than
4000 prehistoric sites dating from about 550 AD to 1270 AD. The
dating is done by the tree ring technique which they claim is more
accurate than the carbon-14 test, particularly if one is determining
the date within the past 2000 years. They can even analyze timbers
that are charred and claim that they can determine the precise year
that the tree was cut down. It seems that for each year and location,
there is a master calendar obtained by examining the tree rings of
hard woods in that particular area, and they can determine the
climate that existed for each year in times past. Each year in the
past has a characteristic "fingerprint" that is readily recognized by
experts.
Some
40 pueblos and cliff dwellings are visible from park roads and
overlooks, and we did see a good many of them. The most impressive
was the "Cliff Palace" which had 217 rooms and 23 kivas, and housed
about 250 persons. A kiva is a Hopi word for "Ceremonial Room". The
Anasazi may have used them to conduct healing rites and to pray for
rain, luck in hunting, or good crops. A roof of beams and mud covered
each kiva, and access was by ladder through a hole in the center.
Each has a small hole in the floor called a Sipapu, a symbolic
entrance to the underworld. While the largest dwelling was the "Cliff
Palace", the most perilous site was the "Balcony House", and this was
a difficult site to reach. One had to climb up and down wooden
ladders that were almost parallel to the cliffside. One only looked
toward the cliff rather than looking down the precipitous cliff wall
into Montezuma Valley below. It was tiring and Pat made the right
decision to omit this experience from her day's itinerary.
On
top of the Mesa, there were many ruin sites, some of which had "Pit
Houses" which apparently were one of the first types of housing
adopted by the Anasazi. Their basic features included a
squarish-shaped living room sunk into the ground and containing a
fire pit with an air deflector and Sipapu, and an ante-chamber with
storage bins (AD 550-AD 750). What is of interest is that the cliff
dwellings were the final form or the most highly evolved form of
housing that developed among these ancient Indians. They left the
flat-topped mesas which were suitable for growing their staples of
maize, beans and squash for the inaccessible sites in the natural
caves or alcoves of the cliffs! The Anasazi people were particularly
skilled at making finely woven baskets and this art preceded that of
making pottery. They used the baskets to collect and hold water. In
setting out the periods of cultural development, archaeologists speak
of 1) "The Basketmakers" (AD 100-550), 2) "The Modified Basketmakers"
(AD 550-AD 750), 3) "The Developmental Pueblo" (AD 750-AD 1100), and
finally, 4) "The Classic or Great Pueblo Period" (AD 1100-AD
1300).
We
were fortunate to be at Mesa Verde while the Nordenskjold Exibit was
being shown and this is being held in commemoration of the 100th
Anniversary of the visit to Mesa Verde in 1891 by Gustav
Nordenskjold, the young Swedish archaeologist. His explorations were
thorough and well organized and served as modules for all subsequent
studies of this kind. Most of the artifacts were taken home to a
museum in Finland and there reside in their National Museum. Many of
the artifacts were loaned temporarily to our National Park Service
for this special anniversary celebration. He was, in addition to
being a fine archaeologist, a very good photographer, and left over
150 photos of his early findings. Unfortunately, he died shortly
after returning to Sweden of tuberculosis at the young age of 26. It
was his shipping of the artifacts back to Scandinavia that incited
the first efforts on our part to protect the archaeological resources
of Mesa Verde.
On
our way back to Albuquerque, we stopped off to see the Aztec Ruins,
another Natural Monument, and yet another site of Anasazi presence.
It was misnamed Aztec when the early Anglo settlers in this area
thought it had been built by the Aztecs of Central Mexico. The chief
interest here was the Great Kiva, the largest in the southwest. After
leaving Aztec, we returned to Albuquerque, visiting en route the
Jemez and Zia Indian Reservations.
While
in Albuquerque, we revisited "Old Town", a collection of art and gift
shops housed in old buildings on the site, and we also enjoyed our
first visit to the Cultural Museum of the Rio Grande Pueblo Tribes.
It is a non-profit organization beautifully housed in a round adobe
type of building with a central area reserved for shows and theater
performances, and surrounded by a fine museum and shops displaying
every facet of Indian art and craftsmanship. Profits from this
cooperative enterprise are funneled back to the reservations to
support the arts of the people and their educational
programs.
Our
trip enriched us with a further knowledge of our Natural Parks and of
the native people who inhabited our country before the arrival of
Christopher Columbus. It was he who called these people Indians,
thinking he had found a way to India by sailing west across the
Atlantic Ocean. At one time, I saw a quote which said "A man traces
the world over to find what he needs and returns home to find it". In
some respects, this is true in our case because after returning home,
I have innumerable books which will amplify the information I
acquired during the actual trip itself.
With Love,

Dad
CEJ/ngb
T10/4/91
or